Dreamers Next Move

-
" 
To be American, to live and grow up in this country, is to dream. Like the generations of immigrants before them, my parents understood that, beyond all the economic opportunities and relative political stability of this country, the United States is a place that allows you to dream, to believe that hard work will allow for a better tomorrow. It’s a country of immigrants, and it offered the best opportunities for their family 
"

Fernando Espina Casas writes that DACA gave him a shot at a promising future. He, among other Dreamers, has spoken out at protests and events, arguing that he is depends on this policy. People argue that this is an important strategy in response to the program's overturning. It employs careful use of pathos to influence others to rise up by educating them on the matter and building solidarity.

Others argue that Dreamers, as non-citizens, should into engage in civil disobedience. This is mainly because of the danger associated with it, given that Dreamers must remain in lawful status to receive DACA. They argue the following:
  • First, the president exercises "prosecutorial discretion" to "defer action" by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement ("ICE") to remove illegal aliens whose removal is not considered a "priority" by the administration, in order to concentrate immigration-enforcement resources on "priority" categories such as spies, terrorists, and "aliens convicted of certain felony offenses."
  • Second, the president exercises his statutory "parole" authority to allow deferred-action illegal aliens to leave the United States and return without a visa.
  • Third, the president claims and exercises unilateral authority to exempt unlimited numbers of deferred-action illegal aliens from the definition of "unauthorized aliens" for purposes of IRCA, thereby permitting the Secretary of Homeland Security to issue EADs to the very aliens that IRCA aims to exclude from the U.S. labor market.
They believe that Dreamers, when engaging in civil disobedience, are acting counterintuitively, given that such action can cost them their American life for something as unconstitutional. 
Regardless of the legality of the situation or not, overturning a policy that was put in place to aid the illegal youth is cruel. These Dreamers have put trust in the country, hoping that they can finally come out of the shadows and blossom into their fullest potential. It is argued that the Dreamers need to show their worth to the country in peaceful manners, influencing others who may not be affected to rise up and advocate for them too. 


Works Consulted:

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/storywall/american-dreamers/stories/fernando-espino-casas

https://cis.org/President-Obamas-Deferred-Action-Program-Illegal-Aliens-Plainly-Unconstitutional

Comments

  1. AnonymousDecember 6, 2017 at 6:20 PM

    Aye Myat Mon
    This is such an interesting case of civil injustice. Your blog post illustrates great details about others' arguments about what should be done. I found the starting quote also very inspiring. However, I'd like to know your point of view on what you believe is the best action for the Dreamers. Could you elaborate on that?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Journey through Argument

-
Writing 150 was a class that I must admit I was a little anxious to take. With thoughts like "the class is rigged" and "the prompts are difficultly broad and worded" circulating through my head, I gre nervous of what to expect. However, to my surprise I began to recognize the importance of Writing and this class to the development of collegiate scholarship. I would learn lessons that can not only be used in the academic aspects of my life but the social and ethical areas as well. The foundational takeaway from this course for me is the idea that as writers and members of our various communities, we are constantly creating arguments about who we are and the ideas we feel passionately for. This was especially true in the workshops where we focused on developing writing skills to best become masters of rhetoric. In every skill or tactic we use in our writing, we are saying something about ourselves and our point of view in writing. Learning how to center arguments th
Read more

It Doesn't Matter If You're Black or White or LATINO

-
"The contradictions, hypocrisies and lies of the history of the nation provoked a certain anger. There was the obvious social injustice of living in the country as Chicanos and Mexicanos, all being programmed to become laborers. None of us were being programmed to enter college. There was a realization that the drop-out rate was not our own failure, but that of the system which preprogrammed us. The failure on our part was we bought into it, and we accepted that was all we could do" - Moctesuma Esparza   A healthy and well nourished upbringing during early childhood is crucial to positively developing the future adults and leaders of the nation. The inequities seen in the East Los Angeles School Districts in the dawn of the Civil Rights era of the 1960s emphasized the need for change. Much of the Civil Rights battle up to this time has been seen from and black and white lens, failing to capture the injustices to Latinos (especially in urban locations). In trying to obt
Read more

Logical Fallacies: Introduction

-
"And maybe that is what we have, in fact, become. For Donald Trump’s refusal to condemn the murderous white supremacists in Charlottesville finally confirms what has become increasingly obvious: The current president of the United States isn’t a real American." -Paul Krugman I n anti-trump article titled, "When the President is Un-American", Paul Krugman makes many remarks against trump, his actions, and views in efforts to show how unconnected he is to the American people. When analyzing the manner in which Trump addressed the violent, bigoted acts that occurred in Charlottesville more recently, he made the remark stated above. Trump failed, in his address, to describe the white-supremacist status of the man who ran his car into the protestors. Logical fallacy can be described simply as an error in logic/reasoning, especially while making a claim or argument. It is logical fallacy to base such a minuscule wrongdoing to credit such a loaded and intricate claim/arg
Read more